up vote 6 down vote favorite

In an excellent answer, Gene G provides a deep link into Family Search where an OP can browse images of lists of passengers arriving in Baltimore in the early twentieth century.

If the next immigrant ancestor considered by that OP happened to arrive through New Orleans, then he will need to come back to post a new question asking for Gene or someone else to find the appropriate FS link. Because he (or she) still has no idea how the information provided last time was located.

An alternative approach would be to provide an extended answer on how to filter the list of collections available on Family Search so that some of the genealogical expertise evident here can be shared.

Which type of response truly deserves a {Nice Answer} - one that passes on a few snippets of arcane knowledge or one that empowers the questioner to improve her own practice?

share
If you are tempted to respond in terms of the number of questions that might be asked under each regime, be aware that I regard that as ABSOLUTELY IRRELEVANT to my question. – Fortiter Jan 7 at 1:16
4  
I'd suggest leaving a comment suggesting that Gene G add the search process, or adding it in yourself if you feel up to it. I agree it's best to teach as well as to answer. – jmort253 Jan 7 at 1:26
Thanks for the feedback. I expanded the answer a bit to suggest techniques for fishing in Chesapeake and other bays. – Gene Golovchinsky Jan 17 at 23:47

1 Answer

up vote 2 down vote

"Which type of response truly deserves a {Nice Answer}"

Both types do. Teaching someone to fish is valuable and giving someone the fish they need is valuable. I don't believe it's and 'either or' question. Obviously doing both is even better (ie answering the specific problem the OP has while teaching the OP how to do it themselves in the future if they have a similar problem by showing them how you found the information). However there will be many cases when the answerer only does one or the other (answers the problem or teaches how to answer the problem). Both are valuable in their own right.

share
1  
Many 'Nice Answers' also come about after a few edits anyways. That said, developing a culture that strives for constant improvement and doesn't settle for mediocrity is a great target to aim for. I think that we all need to get over the fear of stepping on others' toes when it comes to editing and just do it to make the answers or questions better. – Canadian Girl Scout♦ Jan 8 at 4:34

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged